Guidelines for Clinical Diagnosis and Treatment of Traditional Chinese Medicine Orthopedics: Simple thoracolumbar Fractures
This guideline proposes the diagnosis, differentiation, treatment, and functional rehabilitation of simple thoracolumbar fractures. This guideline is applicable for the diagnosis and treatment of adult traumatic thoracolumbar fractures. This guide is suitable for clinical physicians in orthopedics, integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine orthopedics, traditional Chinese medicine, rehabilitation and other related fields.
The following terms and definitions apply to this Guide. Simple thoracolumbar fractures refer to those caused by trauma and without neurological symptoms, which are commonly seen between T10 and L2. Diagnosis [1-3] Traditional Chinese Medicine disease name: Simple thoracolumbar fracture. Western medicine disease name: Simple thoracolumbar fracture. 3.1 Medical history: There is a history of trauma (elderly patients with osteoporosis may not have a significant history of trauma). 3.2 Clinical manifestations 3.2.1 Symptoms include lower back pain, limited mobility, and may be accompanied by swelling. 3.2.2 Local signs may include tenderness, percussion pain, restricted movement, and sometimes swelling, kyphosis, and other deformities. 3.3 Imaging examination: X-rays can determine the type and displacement of fractures; CT examination shows the presence and degree of vertebral plate fracture, articular process fracture, and burst fracture fragments protruding into the spinal canal; MRI examination can display factors and locations of spinal cord compression, degree of spinal canal stenosis, and changes in spinal cord injury. Elderly patients can undergo bone density related examinations. 3.4 Classification 3.4.1 Denis Type A: Compression Fracture; Class B: Burst fracture; Class C: Seat belt fracture; Class D: Fracture and dislocation. 3.4.2 AO classification [4] 3.4.2.1A: vertebral compression type: ① A1: compression fracture; ② A2: Split fracture; ③ A3: Burst fracture. 3.4.2.2B type: Traction double column fracture: ① B1: Posterior column injury mainly involving ligaments; ② B2: Bone based posterior column injury; ③ B3: Injury to the anterior intervertebral disc. 3.4.2.3C category: Rotating double column injury: ① C1: Class A fracture with rotation; ② C2: Class B fracture with rotation; ③ C3: Rotational shear damage. 3.4.3 Classification of spinal stability after injury [5] 3.4.3.1 Stability fractures: Mild and moderate compression fractures, with intact posterior column of the spine. Simple fractures of the transverse process, spinous process, and vertebral plate are also considered stable fractures. 3.4.3.2 Unstable fracture: ① Two out of three columns have fractures; ② Burst fracture: After a mid column fracture, a fracture fragment in the posterior part of the vertebral body protrudes into the spinal canal, with the possibility of nerve damage; ③ Accumulated fractures and dislocations of the anterior, middle, and posterior columns are often accompanied by symptoms of nerve damage. 3.5 Differential diagnosis 3.5.1 Early stage of spinal tuberculosis only has mild back and waist pain. As the disease progresses, there may be low-grade fever, night sweats, fatigue, weight loss, decreased appetite, local pain and radiating pain, abnormal posture, spinal deformities, cold abscesses, and in late stage, spinal cord compression may lead to paralysis. The X-ray shows disappearance of lumbar lordosis and posterior convexity deformity of thoracic vertebrae; Vertebral destruction, with cavities or dead bones, and narrow intervertebral spaces; There is a shadow of abscess; When there is tuberculosis in the vertebral arch, the vertebral arch becomes blurred or disappears. CT and MRI examinations are helpful for early diagnosis. The determination of erythrocyte sedimentation rate, C-reactive protein, etc. in the laboratory can provide assistance for diagnosis. 3.5.2 Early stage spinal tumors lack characteristic clinical manifestations and are often diagnosed in the middle to late stages. Their typical clinical manifestations include local pain, neurological dysfunction, local masses, or spinal deformities, and the symptoms worsen progressively. X-ray images show destruction and uniform compression of the vertebral body, normal intervertebral space, and often invade one or both vertebral arches. CT,MRI, Pathological examination can improve the accuracy of spinal tumor diagnosis. 4 Stages and Dialectical Typing
This syndrome differentiation is determined based on the "Guiding Principles for Clinical Research of Traditional Chinese Medicine New Drugs" [6], "Diagnostic and Therapeutic Criteria for Traditional Chinese Medicine Diseases" [1], and "Traditional Chinese Medicine Orthopedics" [7], combined with literature research. In clinical practice, three-stage syndrome differentiation is the main approach, but it needs to be combined with factors such as patient age and physical condition to achieve comprehensive syndrome differentiation. 4.1 Stages: 4.1.1 Early stage: usually within 1-2 weeks after injury. 4.1.2 Phase 2: 3-6 weeks after injury. 4.1.3 Late stage: 7-8 weeks after injury. 4.2 Dialectical classification: 4.2.1 Qi stagnation and blood stasis syndrome: commonly seen in the early stage of injury, with local swelling, severe pain, poor gastric absorption, constipation, thin and white tongue coating, and tight pulse. For those with less bloating and difficulty urinating, the syndrome is characterized by blood stasis obstruction and bladder gasification disorder. If there is persistent local pain, bloating and pain in the abdomen, constipation, thick and greasy coating, and strong pulse, the syndrome belongs to blood stasis and qi stagnation, and the organs and qi are blocked. 4.2.2 Syndrome of disharmony between blood and body: Commonly seen in the middle stage of injury, although the swelling and pain have subsided, the movement is still restricted, the tongue is dark red, the coating is thin and white, and the pulse is slow. 4.2.3 Liver and Kidney Deficiency Syndrome: Commonly seen in the late stage of injury, with soreness in the waist and weak legs, weakness in the limbs, dull pain in the affected area after movement, pale tongue coating, and thin pulse deficiency. 5 Treatment 5.1 Treatment Principles [7,8] Follow the principles of reduction, fixation, medication treatment, and functional exercise. Non surgical treatment is mainly used for stable fractures, while surgical treatment should be considered for unstable fractures. For osteoporotic fractures, percutaneous vertebroplasty (PVP) or percutaneous kyphoplasty (PKP) can be chosen. In clinical practice, appropriate treatment methods should be selected based on the specific situation of the patient. 5.2 Treatment Methods 5.2.1 Non Surgical Treatment (Recommended Level: B) [9-13] Non surgical treatment methods mainly include bed rest, pillow support for lumbar and back muscle function exercise reduction, traction and over extension compression, two table reduction, ankle suspension reduction, and external fixation braces. Suitable for stable fractures. 5.2.1.1 Resting method for lumbar and back muscle function exercise: The patient lies supine on a hard bed, with a soft pillow 5-10cm high placed at the fracture site. When the pain can be tolerated, the lumbar and back muscle exercise should be carried out as soon as possible. You can use the supine arch shaped exercise method or the prone position flying swallow water exercise method. Practice should start as early as possible. If the injury lasts for more than one week, the reduction effect may be affected due to hematoma organization and anterior longitudinal ligament contraction. Encourage patients to actively practice exercises, gradually prolong the duration of muscle contractions, and pay attention to exercise safety. 5.2.1.2 Traction over extension pressing method: The patient lies prone on a hard bed, holding onto the head of the bed with both hands. One assistant stands on the side of the patient's head, holding their armpits with both hands, while the other assistant stands on the side of their feet, holding their ankles with both hands. Both assistants apply force simultaneously and gradually perform traction. After reaching a certain level, the foot side assistant gradually lifts both lower limbs off the bed surface, allowing the spine to receive sufficient traction and extension. When the muscles relax, the intervertebral space, and the anterior longitudinal ligament are pulled apart, the compressed vertebral body is pulled apart, and the kyphotic deformity is flattened. 5.2.1.3 Two table reduction method: Use two tables of different heights, with a height difference of 25-30cm, arranged flat together. Place the patient on the table with their head facing the high table. Then gradually move the edge of the high table to the inner side of the upper arm and under the chin, and gradually move the low table to the middle of the thigh. With the help of the patient's weight, suspend the chest and waist. At this point, the surgeon can use their palm or another table to support the patient's abdomen and slowly lower it to reduce pain and achieve the goal of spinal hyperextension. After 2-5 minutes, the chest and waist of the spine are significantly hyperextended, and immediately a plaster vest or metal chest and waist hyperextension bracket is applied for fixation. The entire reset process should also pay attention to safety. 5.2.1.4 Two ankle suspension reduction method: The patient lies prone on the reduction bed and lifts both ankles in the air. If there is no reset bed, a pulley can also be installed on the roof beam to lift both feet up and slowly suspend them, allowing the thoracolumbar spine to be over extended and reset. After reduction, attention should be paid to using an overextended splint to maintain the reduction effect, and to maintaining exercise of the lower back muscles. Otherwise, in the late stage, spinal joint stiffness, contraction, and muscle atrophy may occur. The entire reset process should also pay attention to safety. 5.2.1.5 External fixation braces: After strict bed rest treatment, patients can wear spinal external fixation braces to get out of bed and move around according to the situation. The wearing time of the brace is 3-6 months. Simultaneously engage in lower back muscle function exercises. 5.2.2 Percutaneous vertebroplasty (PVP) or kyphoplasty (PKP) (recommended grade: B) [14-17]
Mainly suitable for vertebral compression fractures caused by osteoporosis, without spinal canal occupation or nerve damage. Perform anti osteoporosis treatment after surgery. 5.2.3 Surgical treatment (recommended level: B) [18-21] 5.2.3.1 Indications
Non surgical treatment is expected to achieve satisfactory results for most simple thoracolumbar fractures. But in some cases, certain types of fractures require surgical treatment. The following are the main reference indications for surgical treatment: ① Patients with combined spinal cord and nerve injuries. ② All C-type fractures. ③ Angle formation exceeding 30 °, vertebral compression exceeding 50%, and spinal canal invasion exceeding 30% in A3 and B types MRI confirms the presence of intervertebral disc injury. ⑤ Those who have completed relevant examinations after admission and have no contraindications for surgery. 5.2.3.2 Surgical methods: ① Anterior surgery. ② Posterior surgery. ③ Combined anterior and posterior surgery. 5.2.4 Drug therapy (recommended level: C) [22, 23] 5.2.4.1 Treatment principles for qi stagnation and blood stasis syndrome: promoting qi circulation, reducing swelling and relieving pain. Prescription: Fu Yuan Huo Xue Tang (Medical Invention) with modifications. Composition: Chaihu, Tianfen, Danggui Tail, Honghua, Licorice, Pangolin, Wine soaked Rhubarb, Wine soaked Peach Kernel, etc. (Recommended level: D) It is also possible to use modified versions of Dixia Zhuyu Tang, Taohe Chengqi Tang, or Dacheng Tang. Or take the corresponding traditional Chinese patent medicines and simple preparations orally and apply the corresponding plaster externally. 5.2.4.2 Treatment principles for disharmony between blood and blood: promoting blood circulation and nourishing the body, connecting bones and tendons. Prescription: Jiegu Zijin Dan ("Miscellaneous Diseases Source and Flow Rhinoceros Candle") with modifications. Composition: ground beetle worm, frankincense, myrrh, natural copper, drynaria, rhubarb, dragon's blood, borax, angelica, etc. (Recommended level: D) Or choose the corresponding traditional Chinese patent medicines and simple preparations for oral use and apply the corresponding plaster externally. 5.2.4.3 Treatment principles for liver and kidney deficiency syndrome: tonifying the liver and kidneys, regulating qi and blood. Prescription: Six Ingredient Rehmannia Decoction (Direct Formula for Pediatric Drug Diagnosis) with modifications. Composition: Rehmannia glutinosa, Chinese yam, Poria cocos, Alisma, Cornus officinalis, Peony bark, etc. (Recommended level: D) Bazhen Tang and Zhuangyao Jianshen Tang can also be used. Or take the corresponding traditional Chinese patent medicines and simple preparations orally and apply the corresponding plaster externally.
In addition, medication should be adjusted based on the individual patient's physical condition. 5.3 Functional exercise 5.3.1 Early exercise of lower limb flexion and extension function for non-surgical treatment patients. Pay attention to both upper limb functional exercises and respiratory exercises. After the relief of lower back pain and abdominal distension, one can start performing lower back extension exercises and gradually transition to using braces to move off the bed. (Recommended level: D) 5.3.2 After PVP or PKP treatment, it is recommended to wear waist circumference and engage in ground activities within 24-48 hours to avoid weight-bearing. Early straight leg elevation training can increase passive activities such as bending knees and hips. After the incision in the lower back is healed, the exercise of lower back muscle function can begin. (Recommended level: D) Patients with internal fixation can undergo limb function exercise and respiratory exercise in bed after surgery, and then perform lumbar and back muscle function exercise according to clinical healing conditions, gradually transitioning to brace fixation and off bed ground activity. (Recommended level: D) 5.4 Other therapies can be selected based on the condition, such as moxibustion, traditional Chinese medicine fumigation, traditional Chinese medicine ion introduction, fracture treatment device, etc. 5.5 Prevention and Maintenance [7,24-25]
Conservative treatment for patients should encourage early exercise of the limbs and lower back muscles. Severe patients should not be absolutely bedridden. They should be helped to turn over every 1-2 hours and receive massage to prevent the occurrence of pressure ulcers. Once the condition stabilizes and the patient is strong, they can start practicing exercises. Mild individuals can engage in activities on the ground for 8-12 weeks, but should avoid bending over. After 12 weeks, they can start comprehensive spinal exercises. It is crucial for surgical patients to receive adequate perioperative nursing interventions. Therefore, preoperative psychological guidance and routine care should be provided to reduce negative emotions and ensure smooth surgical treatment; The intraoperative nurse prepares all necessary items for the surgery and is familiar with each step and precautions of the surgery; After surgery, attention should be paid to observing changes in the patient's condition and caring for various pipelines. During the treatment process, it is also necessary to prevent the occurrence of deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism.
reference
[1] National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Diagnostic and Therapeutic Efficacy Standards for Traditional Chinese Medicine Diseases [S]. Nanjing, 1994 [2] Chen Xiaoping, edited by Wang Jianping Surgery, 8th edition. People's Health Press, 2013 [3] Sun Chuanxing Clinical Disease Diagnosis Criteria for Recovery and Improvement. People's Military Medical Press, 1998 [4]Magerl F,Aebi M,Gertzbein SD ,et al. A comprehensive classification of thoracic and lumbar injuries[J]. Eur Spine, 1994, 3 (4): 184-201. (Evidence Grading: I AMSTAR Scale Score: 7 points) [5] Denis F. The three column spine and its significance in the classification of acute thoraco lumbar spinal injuries [J] Spine (Phila1976),1983,8(8):817-831. (Evidence grading: Ⅱ MINORS entry score: 14 points) [6] Edited by Zheng Xiaoyu. Guiding Principles for Clinical Research of Traditional Chinese Medicine New Drugs [M]. China Medical Science and Technology Press, 2002 [7] Wang Heming, Huang Guicheng. National Higher Traditional Chinese Medicine College Planning Textbook (9th Edition) "Traditional Chinese Medicine Bone Injury Science". China Traditional Chinese Medicine Press, 2012 [8] Chen Zhongqiang, Liu Zhongjun, Chief Editor of Danggengcheng Spinal Surgery. People's Health Press, 2013 [9] Zou Huanwen. Clinical observation on conservative treatment of simple thoracolumbar compression fractures with traditional Chinese medicine [J]. Liaoning Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2014, 41 (5): 934-935. (Evidence grading: II Jadad scale score: 4 points) [10] Shi Hongjun, Xu Shaode, Zuo Tianhu. Pillow treatment for 42 cases of simple thoracolumbar compression fractures [J]. Modern Distance Education of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2011, 10 (1): 43-44. (Evidence grading: II MINORS entry score: 14 points) [11] Huang Shuzhao. Modified Five point Support Method for 162 cases of simple thoracolumbar compression fractures [J]. Chinese Journal of Orthopedics, 2005, 15 (10): 38-39. (Evidence grading: I) AMSTAR scale score: 7 points) [12] Wang Xikui, Yuan Qinghua. Observation of 28 cases of simple thoracolumbar compression fractures treated with comprehensive traditional Chinese medicine [J]. Journal of Practical Chinese Medicine, 2015, 31 (8) : 751-752. (Evidence grading: II MINORS entry score: 14 points) [13] Liu Zhenhua. Clinical observation of modified braces in the treatment of thoracolumbar flexion compression fractures [M]. Master's thesis, Heilongjiang University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2010:1-61. (Evidence grading: Ⅰ Jadad scale score: 3 points) [14] Yang Huilin, Yuan HA, Chen Liang, et al. Vertebroplasty for the treatment of elderly osteoporotic spinal compression fractures [J]. Chinese Journal of Orthopedics, 2003, 23 (5): 262-265 (Evidence grading: II Jadad scale score: 4 points) [15] Garfin SR, Yuan HA, Reiley MA. New technologies in spine: kyphoplasty and verticality for the treatment of painful orthopedic compression fractures [J] Spine,2001,26(14):1511 ~1515. (Evidence grading: AMSTAR scale score: 7 points) 6 [16] Zoarski GH, Snow P, Olan WJ, et al. Percutane verticality for osteoporotic vertical compressive fracture: quantitative prospective evaluation of long term outcomes [J] Vasc Interv Radiol , 2002,13(2):139 ~148. (Evidence grading: II MINORS entry score: 14 points) [17] Kado DM, Browner WS, Palermo L, et al. Vertebral fractures and mortality in older women: prospective study [J] Arch Interv Med, 1999, 159 (6): 1215-1220. (Evidence Grading: II MINORS entry score: 14 points) [18] Altay M, Ozkurt B, Aktekin CN, et al. Treatment of unstable thora pyramid junction burst fractures with short-term segment pos primary fixation in Magerl type A fractures [J] Eur Spine ,2007,16(8):1145-1155. (Evidence grading: Jadad entry score: 4 points) [19] Li He, Xing Gengyan, Yang Chuanduo, et al. Biomechanics research and clinical application of spinal internal fixation system [J]. Chinese Journal of Reconstructive Surgery, 2008, 22 (8): 923-927 (Evidence grading: II Jadad entry score: 4 points) [20] Schulte TL, Leistra F, Bullmann V, et al. Disc height reduction in adjacent cent segments and clinical outcomes 10 years after lumbar 360 degrees music [J] Eur Spine ,2007,16(12):2152-2158. (Evidence grading: AMSTAR scale score: 8 points) [21] Peng Jun, Xu Jianguang. Research progress on thoracolumbar spine fracture surgery [J] Chinese Journal of Repair and Reconstructive Surgery, December 2009, 23 (12), 1506-1508. (Evidence Grading: II Jadad Scale Score: 4 points) [22] Lei Jie, Dong Xiaojun, Research Progress on Conservative Treatment of Simple thoracolumbar Compression Fractures [J], Integrated Chinese and Western Medicine Research, 2013, (5) 6:320-321 (Evidence grading: III AMSTAR scale score: 8 points) [23] Li Zhifei, Zhong Yuanming, Zhou Binbin et al. Research progress on conservative treatment of simple thoracolumbar compression fractures [M], Journal of Guangxi University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2006, 9 (4): 87-90 (Evidence grading: II AMSTAR scale score: 8 points) [24] Yang Jing, Tang Kunhong, Zhu Sai, et al. Perioperative nursing of 73 cases of thoracolumbar fractures treated with pedicle screw rod system internal fixation [J] Qilu Nursing Journal, 2010, 16 (26): 58-60. (Evidence Grading: II Jadad Scale Score: 4 points) [25] Yang Weiguang, Weng Yongqian, Ou Zhifeng, et al. Single stage pedicle screw fixation for the treatment of unstable thoracolumbar fractures [J]. Contemporary Medicine, 2010, 16 (24): 89-90. (Evidence Grading: III MINORS Item Score: 16 points) Explanation: In 2014, the National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine issued a revision project for clinical diagnosis and treatment guidelines and prevention and treatment standards of traditional Chinese medicine. At the same time, in order to implement the "2014 Public Health Service Subsidy Fund for Traditional Chinese Medicine" project, the National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine, the Chinese Association of Traditional Chinese Medicine, The Orthopedics Branch of the Chinese Medical Association has entrusted the Orthopedics Department of Taihe County Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital to actively carry out the "Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Treatment of Common Diseases in Traditional Chinese Medicine Orthopedics" for simple thoracolumbar vertebral fractures The development of the project (task number: SATCM-2015-BZ [089]) aims to provide reference and standards for the clinical diagnosis and treatment of simple thoracolumbar fractures with traditional Chinese medicine, improve the level of traditional Chinese medicine clinical diagnosis and treatment of simple thoracolumbar fractures, and promote the progress and development of traditional Chinese medicine. 1. Retrieval of clinical evidence
Retrieve the China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) Academic Literature Database, Chinese Science and Technology Journal Full text Database (VIP), China Biomedical Literature Database (CBM), Wanfangda Database, China Traditional Chinese Medicine Literature Database, China Excellent Doctoral and Master's Thesis Full text Database, Disease Diagnosis and Treatment Database, Traditional Chinese Medicine Diagnosis and Treatment Standards Database, PubMed, CochraneLibrary, EMBASE Database, and the National Food and Drug Administration (SFDA) database; Retrieve clinical trials registered in the Chinese Clinical Trial Registry (www.chictr. org) and the American Clinical Trial Registry (www.clinicaltrials. gov); Search guidelines related databases include The National Guideline Clearinghouse (NGC) in the United States (http://www.guideline. gov) and the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) in the United Kingdom( http://www.nice.org.uk/ )The Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) has not set language or research design restrictions for literature search, and the deadline is June 30, 2015. Chinese search terms: simple thoracolumbar spine, fracture, thoracolumbar spine fracture, thoracic spine fracture, lumbar spine fracture. English search term: Simple thoracolumbar fractures thoracolumbar fractures thoracopractices lumbarfractures. According to the characteristics of different databases, conduct comprehensive searches by combining theme words with free words and keywords. 2. Literature evaluation
Evaluate each clinical literature retrieved using the following methods. (1) Evaluation of clinical randomized trials: Using the Cochrane bias risk assessment tool, select literature with a modified Jadad scale score of 3 or higher as evidence for the guidelines. (2) Evaluation of non randomized clinical trials: using MINORS item scoring. There are a total of 12 evaluation indicators, each of which is scored 0-2 points. The highest score for the first 8 studies without a control group is 16 points; The last four studies with a control group scored a total of 24 points. 0 points indicate no reporting; 1 point indicates reporting but insufficient information; A score of 2 indicates that the report has been reported and sufficient information has been provided. Select literature with a total score of 13 or higher as evidence for therapeutic recommendations. Many literature titles are randomized controlled, but the content is essentially non randomized controlled, such as grouping by order of visit. This type should be classified as a non randomized trial.
If there are obvious quality issues, such as discrepancies between the sample size of the classification statistics and the total sample size of the group, poor theoretical analysis
The author's non clinical treatment reports should be directly excluded without the need for scale scoring.
(3) Meta analysis evaluation: The AMSTAR scale can be used to evaluate the quality of literature. The evaluation results for each item can be
Divided into three types: "yes", "no", "unclear" or "not mentioned", and given a score, such as "yes" being 1 point, "no"
'Not clear' or 'not mentioned' score 0 out of 11, AMSTAR score 0-4 indicates low quality, and 5-8 indicates moderate
A score of 9-11 indicates high quality. Select literature with a score of 5 or above as evidence.
3. Evidence evaluation grading and literature recommendation grading
3.1 Clinical studies that meet the aforementioned quality requirements can serve as the basis for guidelines: large sample randomized controlled trials with high results
Evidence of secondary or low-intensity recommendations based on small sample randomized controlled trials and non randomized controlled trials
Evidence. In addition, recommendations can be formed through expert consensus based on the results of literature research.
Table 1 Classification and Recommendation Level of Literature
Classification of Traditional Chinese Medicine Literature
Recommended level
Large sample size, randomized study, clear results, false positive
At least 2 Level I research results support A
The error rate of sexual or false negative is very low
II Small sample, randomized study, uncertain results, false
Only one Level I research result supports B
The error rate of positive and/or false negative is relatively high
III Non randomized, simultaneous controlled trials and based on ancient literature
C is only supported by Level II research results
Expert consensus presented
IV Non random, Historical Control, and Contemporary Expert Consensus
At least one Level III research result supports D
Case Report V, Non Controlled Study and Expert Opinion
Only level IV or V research results support E
According to the classification criteria for literature:
(1) The literature classification method for the revision of traditional Chinese medicine clinical diagnosis and treatment guidelines is implemented in accordance with the "Classification Standards for Traditional Chinese Medicine Literature Basis" proposed by Wang Shouchuan, Yu Shun, Zhao Xia, Dai Qigang, Chen Zhengguang, and Xu Shan in the "Reference Basis for Evidence Grading and Recommendation Strength" section of the "ZYYXH/T Chinese Medicine Industry Standards for Traditional Chinese Medicine Clinical Diagnosis and Treatment Guidelines" (for review). Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2012; 27 (11): 2759-2763.
(2) The recommendation level (or recommendation strength) is divided into five levels: A, B, C, D, and E. The intensity is highest at level A and decreases in sequence.
(3) In the "research topic grading" of this standard, large sample and small sample are defined as: large sample: high-quality single randomized controlled trial reports or systematic review reports with ≥ 100 cases. Small sample:<100 high-quality single articles (4) Level III "Expert consensus based on ancient literature" refers to those recorded in ancient medical books, used throughout history, and reached consensus among contemporary experts. In Level IV, 'Contemporary Expert Consensus' refers to the consensus reached by contemporary experts through survey opinions. The 'expert opinions' in Level V only refer to individual expert opinions. 4. Guidelines Working Group 2015 Clinical Diagnosis and Treatment Guidelines for Traditional Chinese Medicine Orthopedics Expert Guidance Group: Leader: Sun Shuchun, Zhu Liguo; Deputy team leader: Liu Jun, Zhan Hongsheng; Members: Wang Yongjun, Yang Haiyun, Zhang Li, Wang Ping, Li Sheng, Hua Leng, Xiangyang, Zhang Xiaofeng, Wu Bo, Gao Shutu, Tan Yuanchao, Lin Dingkun; Secretary: Zhang Jun, Yu Jie, Pan Jianke, Hong Kunhao; Drafted by Yu Qihua (Taihe County Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital) for the "Guidelines for Diagnosis and Treatment of Common Diseases in Traditional Chinese Medicine Orthopedics - Simple thoracolumbar Vertebral Fracture (Development)". The project working group for the "Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Treatment of Common Diseases in Traditional Chinese Medicine Orthopedics - Simple thoracolumbar Vertebral Fracture (Development)" is led by Yu Qihua and Li Jinxue (Guidance Team Leader); Deputy team leaders: Li Junyu, Liu Xu; Secretary and members: Chen Xiaolong, Xin Kun, Liu Wei, Zhang Wensheng. Expert review meeting for the "Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Treatment of Common Diseases in Traditional Chinese Medicine Orthopedics - Simple thoracolumbar Vertebral Fracture (Development)" (Evaluation Draft): Leader: Yu Qihua (Chief Physician of Taihe County Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital), Li Jinxue (Chief Physician of Wangjing Hospital, Chinese Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences); Deputy team leaders: Li Junyu (Deputy Chief Physician of Taihe County Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital), Liu Xu (Deputy Chief Physician of Taihe County Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital); Members: Wang Feng (Chief Physician of the First Affiliated Hospital of Anhui University of Traditional Chinese Medicine), Liu Liang (Chief Physician of the Second Affiliated Hospital of Anhui University of Traditional Chinese Medicine), Liu Dechun (Chief Physician of the Second Affiliated Hospital of Anhui University of Traditional Chinese Medicine), Liu Jun (Chief Physician of the Wendeng Orthopedic Hospital of Shandong Province), Wu Song (Professor of the Statistics Research Department of Anhui University of Traditional Chinese Medicine), Zhao Fei (Deputy Chief Physician of the Wuhu Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital of Anhui Province), Hang Boya (Chief Physician of the Nanjing Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital of Jiangsu Province), Chen Qiqing (Deputy Chief Physician of the Gansu Provincial Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital), Hu Jigong (Chief Physician of the Lu'an City Central Hospital of Anhui Province), Lu Jianhua (Chief Physician of the Zhejiang Provincial Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital), Yao Xianjie (Chief Physician of the Taihe County Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital) Chief physician, Chen Xiaolong (attending physician at Taihe County Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital), Xin Kun (attending physician at Taihe County Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital) Liu Wei (attending physician at Taihe County Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital) and Zhang Wensheng (physician at Taihe County Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital).




